Executive summary: Jessica Simpson has drawn attention by posting a behind-the-scenes video from the set of Hulu’s ‘All’s Fair,’ where she showcases elaborate prosthetic makeup designed to give her character a botched plastic surgery appearance. The video, shared on Instagram, comes as the show faces severe criticism from reviewers.
In the social media clip, Simpson can be seen giggling and exclaiming, “I mean, this face!” as she displays exaggerated facial features including large cheeks, lips, and a distorted nose piece. She danced to Peggy Lee’s “Fever” while wearing a dress that she lifted to reveal fishnet stockings and a garter, adding to the playful yet intense vibe of the character.
Simpson introduced the character, Lee-Ann, as an “ultimate badass with a heart of gold” in her caption, emphasizing that it took six hours in prosthetics to bring her to life. She expressed deep connection to the role, stating that she could “disappear into” Lee-Ann with “real depth and emotion,” and appreciated the unique opportunity that had never been offered to her before.
The character’s storyline involves seeking revenge on a cheating ex-boyfriend, a plot that appears inspired by the tumultuous relationship between Pamela Anderson and Tommy Lee. Simpson’s appearance is in the third episode of ‘All’s Fair,’ which premiered its first three episodes on Tuesday, November 4, 2025.
‘All’s Fair’ is a legal drama created by Ryan Murphy and features a star-studded cast including Sarah Paulson, Glenn Close, and Naomi Watts. Despite the high-profile talent, the series has been widely panned, earning a shocking 0% rating on Rotten Tomatoes and being labeled the “worst TV show” by some critics and viewers.
Simpson had previously teased her “very intense” role in a May interview with Deadline, where she mentioned that the prosthetics transformation initially took eight hours. She also shared her excitement about working with co-star Kim Kardashian, noting that their children are best friends and that the collaboration felt natural and fun on set.
Director Anthony Hemingway defended the show in response to the backlash, telling the Hollywood Reporter that “the show takes a minute to get into gear” but is “refreshing and creatively fulfilling.” He also addressed criticism of Kardashian’s acting, asserting that no single person should define the totality of the series.
As of now, Simpson has not publicly reacted to the rampant negative reviews, but the video post suggests she remains proud of her work. The future of ‘All’s Fair’ may hinge on whether audience reception improves or if Hulu decides to continue the series despite its rocky start.