Alix Earle’s stepmother, Ashley Dupré, sparked controversy by publicly criticizing former ‘Dancing With the Stars’ pro Cheryl Burke after Burke gave Earle a lower score on the show’s Halloween episode, leading to a heated social media response over body-shaming comments. The incident unfolded during Tuesday night’s broadcast, highlighting tensions between judges and audience reactions in the competitive dance series.
During the Halloween-themed episode of ‘Dancing With the Stars’ on October 28, Alix Earle and her professional partner Val Chmerkovskiy performed a tango to Billie Eilish’s ‘bury a friend,’ aiming for a high score in the ninth week of the competition. The routine was well-received, with Earle showcasing her progress in the intense rehearsal process that has previously left her with physical bruises and emotional challenges. The dance placed her at the top of the leaderboard, but the scoring revealed a split among the judges that would soon escalate into a public dispute.
While regular judges Carrie Ann Inaba, Bruno Tonioli, and Derek Hough each awarded Earle and Chmerkovskiy a perfect score of 10, guest judge Cheryl Burke—a former pro on the show—gave them a 9, resulting in a total of 39 out of 40. This single point deduction prevented Earle from achieving a perfect score, a outcome that quickly drew attention from viewers and participants alike. Burke, who returned as a guest judge for the first time in three years, had previously discussed the pressures of scoring on the show, noting that judges often face backlash regardless of their decisions.
Ashley Dupré, who was watching the episode from home with Earle’s younger siblings, captured her immediate reaction in a TikTok video posted on October 29. As Burke revealed the score of 9, Dupré could be heard exclaiming, ‘Oh, go take more Ozempic!’ in a sharp, critical tone. The comment directly referenced Burke’s recent weight loss and appearance, which has been a topic of public discussion, though Burke has consistently denied using Ozempic or other weight-loss medications. Dupré’s children appeared confused by the remark, prompting her to double down by adding, ‘She looks weird. Doesn’t even look like her,’ further intensifying the personal nature of the attack.
The TikTok video quickly garnered mixed reactions from followers, with some users condemning Dupré’s comments as unnecessary and bullying. Critics pointed out that body-shaming is harmful, regardless of the context, and emphasized that Burke’s scoring was a professional judgment, not a personal affront. Others, however, found humor in the situation, laughing at the bluntness of the ‘Ozempic’ reference and expressing similar frustrations with the judging. This divide highlights the broader issues of online behavior and the intense fan culture surrounding reality TV competitions.
Cheryl Burke has been open about her body transformation in recent months, addressing public speculation in a March TikTok video where she clarified that she is not on Ozempic, not sick, and has not undergone cosmetic procedures. Instead, she attributed her weight loss—reportedly 41 pounds—to lifestyle changes, including a portion-controlled food delivery service and improved eating habits, while also citing personal struggles such as divorce, sobriety, and trauma. Burke has expressed that the criticism over her appearance has been particularly hurtful, noting that it feels worse than when she faced comments about weight gain earlier in her career.
In the aftermath, the incident raises questions about the dynamics of ‘Dancing With the Stars,’ where judges’ scores often fuel fan debates and social media backlash. Burke had previously spoken with Page Six about the challenges of scoring, explaining that couples cannot be directly compared due to different dance styles and that judges like Carrie Ann Inaba face disproportionate criticism. The show continues to navigate these tensions as it progresses into its 34th season, with Earle remaining a strong contender despite the scoring controversy.
Looking ahead, the fallout from Dupré’s comments may prompt discussions on responsible social media use and the impact of celebrity family members on public perceptions. While Dupré expressed pride in her stepdaughter’s performance in the video’s caption, the focus has shifted to the ethical implications of her remarks. As ‘DWTS’ moves forward, it remains to be seen how such incidents will influence judging transparency and audience engagement in an era where instant reactions can escalate into viral controversies.
