Ashley Tisdale’s playdate with Haylie Duff, the estranged sister of Hilary Duff, has intensified the ongoing ‘toxic’ mom group drama, highlighting celebrity social tensions and family rifts. This event brings renewed public attention to personal disputes among high-profile figures.
On Tuesday, Haylie Duff shared an Instagram photo of her youngest daughter, Lulu, 7, playing under a table with Tisdale’s eldest daughter, Jupiter, 4, captioned ‘Under table shenanigans.’ Tisdale reposted the image to her Stories, publicly affirming their connection. The playdate occurred three weeks after Haylie expressed support for Tisdale by liking an Instagram post promoting Tisdale’s essay about exclusion from a mom group.
In her essay published earlier this month, Tisdale detailed feeling left out of a mom group that includes Hilary Duff, Meghan Trainor, and Mandy Moore. She described seeing social media photos of gatherings she wasn’t invited to and alleged that exclusive text chains fostered cliques. Tisdale’s candid account sparked reactions from those involved and their partners, turning private tensions into public narrative.
Haylie’s endorsement of Tisdale’s perspective marked a clear stance against her sister, Hilary, in the dispute. This added a familial layer to the drama, as Hilary and Haylie have been publicly estranged since 2019, with no photographs together in years. Hilary recently addressed the rift in a new song titled ‘We Don’t Talk,’ performed at her London show, where she expressed a desire to reconcile and understand the silence.
Responses to Tisdale’s essay were pointed, with Hilary Duff’s husband, Matthew Koma, calling Tisdale ‘the most self-obsessed tone deaf person on earth’ on social media. Mandy Moore commented cryptically about mourning changed friendships, and Meghan Trainor and her husband, Daryl Sabara, also engaged subtly. These reactions underscore the personal and public nature of the conflict among the celebrities.
The Duff sisters’ feud has long been speculated, with their last public appearance in 2019. Hilary’s emotional song lyrics suggest ongoing pain and a willingness to address issues, though the estrangement’s exact cause remains unclear. The playdate with Tisdale may signal Haylie’s alignment in the mom group controversy, potentially deepening family divisions.
This incident reflects broader themes in celebrity culture, where social media amplifies personal disputes and mom groups can become sources of both support and exclusion. The involvement of multiple celebrities with large followings invites fan commentary and media scrutiny, blurring lines between private and public life.
Looking ahead, the drama may influence future interactions among the celebrities involved. Whether it leads to reconciliations or further divisions remains to be seen, but it ensures the story stays in the public eye, highlighting the complexities of friendship and family under scrutiny.
