Hulu has renewed the legal drama ‘All’s Fair,’ starring Kim Kardashian, for a second season, announced on November 24, 2025, despite overwhelmingly negative critical reception. The show, which premiered earlier in November, will begin production on its next season in spring 2026, confirming its place in Hulu’s lineup amid a backdrop of viewer enthusiasm and critical disdain.
The renewal was confirmed through Hulu’s social media channels, where the streamer celebrated the series’ strong performance. ‘All’s Fair’ achieved 3.2 million views globally in its first three days, making it Hulu’s most successful scripted premiere in three years. This viewer engagement starkly contrasts with its critical ratings, as the show holds a mere 3% ‘fresh’ score on Rotten Tomatoes, having initially plummeted to 0%. The disconnect between critics and audiences highlights the evolving metrics of success in the streaming era.
Created by Ryan Murphy, known for hits like ‘Glee’ and ‘American Horror Story,’ ‘All’s Fair’ features an ensemble cast including Kim Kardashian as Allura Grant, a high-powered LA lawyer dealing with courtroom and personal scandals while leading a firm of divorce attorneys. Co-stars Sarah Paulson, Glenn Close, Niecy Nash-Betts, Naomi Watts, and Teyana Taylor round out the talented lineup, bringing depth to the campy, dramatic narrative that blends legal intrigue with personal drama.
Critics have been unsparing in their assessments. The Hollywood Reporter’s Angie Han described Kardashian’s acting as ‘stiff and affectless without a single authentic note,’ while Slate’s David Mack likened it to ‘a haunted doll experiencing life for the first time.’ Such reviews contributed to the show’s notorious reputation, yet the cast has embraced the backlash with humor and grace, turning the criticism into a talking point that fueled viewer curiosity.
Kim Kardashian herself responded to the criticism by posting negative reviews on Instagram with the caption, ‘Have you tuned in to the most critically acclaimed show of the year!?!?!?’ Glenn Close, in an interview with Variety, defended Kardashian, praising her seriousness and preparation on set, and noting that she was ‘smart enough to have people around her who she could learn from.’ Close also shared a playful illustration referencing ‘critic bunny stew,’ a nod to her iconic role in ‘Fatal Attraction,’ showcasing the cast’s lighthearted approach to the backlash.
The renewal underscores a growing trend in streaming where audience metrics can outweigh critical opinion. As ‘All’s Fair’ prepares for its second season, it sets a precedent for how platforms may prioritize viewership numbers over traditional reviews. Fans can anticipate more legal drama and personal entanglements when the series returns, potentially solidifying its status as a cult favorite despite—or because of—its polarizing reception.
