Theresa Nist, winner of “The Golden Bachelor,” has alleged that her ex-husband Gerry Turner once joked about killing her and hiding her body during a walk near his home. This revelation came during a podcast appearance, adding a dark twist to their already publicized divorce.
During the November 4 episode of the “Dear Shandy” podcast, Nist recounted a disturbing moment from their relationship. She described how, while walking around Pretty Lake, Turner pointed to a shed and said, “That’s where I’m going to hide your body after I kill you and chop you up.” Nist noted that he wasn’t laughing, which made her feel there was underlying animosity, though she doesn’t believe he intended to harm her. The comment, made over a year after their split, highlights lingering tensions from their brief marriage.
Gerry Turner has disputed Nist’s account, telling TMZ that he laughed during the exchange and calling the allegation “preposterous.” This disagreement underscores the ongoing friction between the former couple, who divorced just three months after their televised wedding in early 2024. Turner’s response suggests that he views the incident as a misremembered joke rather than a serious threat.
Their relationship began on the inaugural season of “The Golden Bachelor,” where Turner chose Nist as his final rose recipient. However, incompatibilities quickly surfaced, including disagreements over retirement plans and living arrangements. Turner has detailed these issues in his memoir, “Golden Years,” where he admits to feeling trapped before their wedding and even contemplating suicide after the divorce. Nist, on the other hand, has emphasized her willingness to care for a sick spouse, referencing her late husband’s health struggles.
The divorce was finalized in April 2024, with both parties citing fundamental differences. Turner has since moved on, announcing his engagement to Lana Sutton last month, while Nist continues to share her perspective through media appearances. This latest allegation adds to the public narrative of their failed marriage, revealing deeper emotional conflicts.
In the broader context, this story reflects the challenges of high-profile relationships and the scrutiny they face. It also touches on themes of mental health, as Turner’s memoir reveals his struggles with depression post-divorce. The incident serves as a cautionary tale about the pressures of reality TV romances and the importance of communication in partnerships.
As both individuals pursue new chapters, this allegation may fuel further public discussion, but it’s unlikely to lead to legal action given Nist’s characterization of it as a joke. The focus now shifts to their personal growth and future endeavors, with fans and media watching closely.