The 2025-26 MLB offseason is underway with a deep class of free agents, headlined by players like Bo Bichette, Kyle Tucker, and Cody Bellinger, as teams across the league assess potential fits to bolster their rosters for the upcoming season. This period marks a critical juncture for franchises aiming to capitalize on available talent without the presence of superstars like Juan Soto or Shohei Ohtani, focusing instead on a roster of impactful hitters and reliable pitchers.
Bo Bichette emerges as a top free agent after a strong bounce-back season, batting .311 with 18 home runs and 94 RBIs for the Toronto Blue Jays. However, his defensive limitations at shortstop, including poor metrics in defensive runs saved, may prompt a position change to second or third base. Potential fits include a reunion with the Blue Jays, who value his offensive production and clubhouse presence, or the San Francisco Giants, who need middle infield upgrades after their second basemen hit just .216 in 2025. Other suitors like the Kansas City Royals could see him as a fit for his contact-hitting style, though payroll constraints may limit their pursuit.
Kyle Tucker is projected to command a contract nearing $400 million despite injury concerns, including a hand fracture that limited his production in the latter part of 2025. His blend of power and speed, with 22 home runs and 25 stolen bases, makes him a coveted asset for teams seeking outfield stability. The Los Angeles Dodgers are a natural fit due to their financial flexibility and need in left field, while the San Francisco Giants could target him to add left-handed power alongside rookie Bryce Eldridge. Tucker’s age (29) and consistent performance make him a high-risk, high-reward signing.
Cody Bellinger, who posted a 5.0 WAR with 29 home runs and 98 RBIs, offers versatility by playing all outfield positions and first base. His 2025 performance was buoyed by a strong showing at Yankee Stadium, but road struggles raise questions about his consistency. The New York Mets are a prime fit to address center field or first base needs, especially if they move on from Pete Alonso, while the New York Yankees might consider a reunion if they prioritize short-term upgrades over long-term commitments. Bellinger’s ability to switch positions enhances his market appeal.
Kyle Schwarber, coming off a 56-home run season, is a key free agent whose power and leadership make him a valuable designated hitter or outfielder. The Philadelphia Phillies are the likely destination given his integral role in their lineup, but the Mets could emerge as a competitor to weaken a division rival and boost their own offense. Schwarber’s durability and clubhouse impact are significant factors, and his decision could influence the balance of power in the National League East.
Other notable hitters include Alex Bregman, who opted out of his contract with the Boston Red Sox after a .273 average and 18 home runs, with the Red Sox, Detroit Tigers, or New York Yankees as potential fits due to his right-handed bat and veteran experience. Pete Alonso, with 38 home runs and 126 RBIs, may return to the Mets but faces a market cautious of his age and defensive limitations, with the Miami Marlins or Washington Nationals as dark horse candidates.
On the pitching side, Dylan Cease’s power arm and durability, with a 97.1 mph fastball and 215 strikeouts in 2025, attract interest from contenders like the Chicago Cubs, where a reunion makes sense, or the San Diego Padres, who need rotation depth. Framber Valdez, with a 3.66 ERA and 192 innings pitched, is a target for the Baltimore Orioles to address their rotation woes or a return to the Houston Astros if payroll allows. These pitchers highlight a market focused on reliability over elite ace status.
The offseason’s trajectory will be shaped by team needs and financial considerations, with the GM meetings in November likely to accelerate signings. The depth of this free agent class, particularly in power hitters, provides opportunities for mid-market teams to make strategic additions without overspending, setting the stage for a competitive 2026 season.