TMZ has released a new installment of its popular “Who’d You Rather?!” feature, focusing on celebrity Halloween costumes that have sparked comparisons. Published in the early hours of October 25, 2025, this gallery invites readers to weigh in on which star’s festive attire they find more appealing, adding an interactive twist to the holiday season.
The first matchup pits Paris Hilton against Casey Boonstra, both paying homage to Britney Spears. Hilton’s choice of the schoolgirl outfit from the “Hit Me Baby One More Time” music video evokes nostalgia, while Boonstra’s “I’m A Slave For You” ensemble brings a sultrier vibe. This contrast allows fans to debate which era of Spears’ career is better represented through costume, highlighting how celebrities often draw inspiration from iconic pop culture moments for their Halloween looks.
In another segment, Lizzo and Saweetie take on the role of Edward Scissorhands, the eerie character known for his scissor-like hands from Tim Burton’s classic film. Their interpretations showcase how different artists can bring unique flair to a Halloween staple, with detailed costumes that capture the essence of the character’s gothic and whimsical nature. This pairing emphasizes the creativity involved in transforming into well-known figures for the holiday.
Avanai Gregg and James Charles are featured as characters from “Avatar,” highlighting their expertise in makeup and transformation. Gregg, renowned for intricate designs, and Charles, a social media sensation, both present blue-skinned Na’vi looks, challenging voters to decide whose artistic execution is more impressive. This comparison underscores the role of skilled makeup in bringing fantasy elements to life during Halloween celebrations.
The gallery is designed for easy navigation, with clickable images that lead to voting options for each pair. This user-friendly approach encourages participation and makes the experience engaging for TMZ’s audience, who often enjoy such lighthearted content. By allowing readers to cast their votes, the feature fosters a sense of community and interaction around celebrity culture.
This “Who’d You Rather?!” series is part of TMZ’s regular offerings, frequently updated with new comparisons that tap into current events or seasons. By leveraging celebrity culture, it drives engagement and keeps readers coming back for more entertainment insights, demonstrating the outlet’s ability to blend news with interactive elements to maintain viewer interest.
As Halloween approaches, these comparisons not only provide amusement but also set trends for costume ideas among the public. The results of the votes could influence what styles become popular at parties and on social media, showing how celebrity endorsements and media features can shape holiday traditions and fashion choices in real time.
Ultimately, TMZ’s “Who’d You Rather?!” serves as a fun, interactive way for fans to engage with celebrity culture during Halloween, blending fashion, nostalgia, and community voting into a cohesive entertainment experience that reflects the playful spirit of the season.