Model Brooks Nader humorously revealed that she and her sisters are ‘just psychos at heart’ during the American Ballet Theatre’s Fall Gala, expressing surprise at the success of their reality show ‘Love Thy Nader’. The Sports Illustrated Swimsuit model shared this lighthearted insight while attending the event with her three sisters, highlighting their unique dynamic and the unexpected resonance with audiences.
At the gala held on Wednesday night, Brooks Nader, 28, joked to Page Six about her disbelief in the show’s popularity, stating, ‘I’m shocked because I know that we’re just psychos at heart.’ She elaborated that the sisters—Mary Holland, Grace Ann, and Sarah Jane—each bring their own distinct personalities to the series, which follows their lives in New York City. Brooks added, ‘I’m like, ‘wow, people resonate with that?’ I guess we’re all more alike than we think,’ suggesting that viewers connect with their authentic, albeit quirky, family interactions.
The reality series, ‘Love Thy Nader,’ has garnered attention for its candid portrayal of the sisters navigating careers, relationships, and personal growth. Brooks, a ‘Dancing With the Stars’ alum, reflected on her own evolution since divorcing Billy Haire in 2024 after four years of marriage. She described entering a ‘single era’ as an exciting discovery of a new version of herself, emphasizing how life changes have shaped her identity and the show’s content.
Brooks’ love life has been a focal point in the media, particularly after Page Six exclusively reported she dated US Open finalists Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner simultaneously this summer. When asked about the rumors on ‘Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen,’ she quipped, ‘a lady never kisses and tells, especially twice,’ playfully acknowledging the attention. Her sister Grace Ann, who was in the audience, chimed in with a witty remark, underscoring their close yet teasing relationship.
The sisters’ bond is marked by playful antics, including temporary social media blocks, which Grace Ann noted they do ‘all the time.’ This dynamic adds to the show’s appeal, showcasing a relatable mix of support and sibling rivalry. Brooks explained that their different ‘sorts of psychos’ personalities contribute to the series’ authenticity, making it a hit among viewers who enjoy unfiltered family stories.
Now embracing her single status, Brooks expressed enthusiasm for exploring new opportunities and meeting people. She advised, ‘Go out, party, have fun,’ and highlighted the ‘layers to the single Brooks,’ indicating a positive outlook on her personal journey. This chapter in her life not only fuels the reality show but also resonates with audiences navigating similar transitions.
The success of ‘Love Thy Nader’ underscores a broader trend in entertainment where real-life stories captivate viewers. Brooks and her sisters’ ability to blend humor with vulnerability has struck a chord, potentially paving the way for more seasons or spin-offs. As they continue to share their adventures, the Naders exemplify how family dynamics can entertain and inspire, leaving fans eager for what comes next.