One week into the 2025 MLB playoffs, ESPN experts have unveiled their bold predictions and hot takes for the remainder of the postseason, drawing from early performances in the division series. The small sample size of October baseball has not deterred analysts from making confident forecasts about teams, players, and potential World Series outcomes.
A recurring theme among the predictions is the possibility that all four division series could extend to a decisive fifth game, a rarity that has only occurred once before in 2012. Despite some teams holding 2-0 leads, the competitive balance among the eight remaining contenders suggests that comebacks are feasible, particularly in matchups like the Dodgers-Phillies and Tigers-Mariners. This underscores the unpredictability of playoff baseball, where momentum can shift rapidly based on a few key plays or pitching performances.
The proliferation of the split-fingered fastball has emerged as a key storyline, with the pitch being thrown at a record rate of 5.7% of all pitches so far in the postseason. The Toronto Blue Jays, in particular, have leveraged splitters effectively, both in pitching and hitting, leading to speculation about their championship potential. Experts note that the success of pitchers like Trey Yesavage and Kevin Gausman could influence pitching strategies across the league in the coming years, much like the cutter revolutionized bullpens in the past.
Several star players are expected to shine throughout the playoffs. Cal Raleigh of the Seattle Mariners is predicted to out-homer other 60-home-run hitters combined, while Jackson Chourio of the Milwaukee Brewers is seen as a potential MVP in both the League Championship Series and World Series. Additionally, relievers like Roki Sasaki, Jhoan Duran, and Andres Munoz are forecasted to post scoreless appearances in critical games, highlighting the importance of bullpen dominance in tight contests.
Team-specific predictions include the Blue Jays averaging an impressive 10 runs per game and potentially sweeping their way to the World Series, thanks to a potent offense and deep pitching roster. Conversely, the New York Yankees, despite a 2-0 deficit, are believed capable of forcing a Game 5 against Toronto, relying on their power hitters to exploit the short porch in right field. The Los Angeles Dodgers are expected to rely heavily on their starting rotation, mirroring the 2019 Washington Nationals’ strategy, to navigate bullpen uncertainties and secure a repeat championship.
The Dodgers-Phillies NLDS is viewed by some as a de facto World Series matchup, but experts caution that other teams like the Brewers, Mariners, or Tigers could emerge as champions. The Brewers’ regular-season success against both Philadelphia and Los Angeles underscores the unpredictability of October baseball, where underdogs often defy odds. This adds an element of suspense, as fans and analysts watch to see if favorites can maintain their form or if surprises will unfold.
As the playoffs progress, these early hot takes will be tested, with the potential for dramatic shifts in narrative. The emphasis on splitter usage, standout performances, and team depth sets the stage for an exciting conclusion to the 2025 MLB season, where every game could redefine expectations and crown a new champion.